Blog

Costco Executive vs Sam's Club Plus vs BJ's Club+ for a US Family of Four in 2026: Which Warehouse Club Pays Back the Fee?

Hejia Zhang
Hejia Zhang
Editor-in-Chief, ShopBack
Costco Executive vs Sam's Club Plus vs BJ's Club+ for a US Family of Four in 2026: Which Warehouse Club Pays Back the Fee?

For a US family of four in 2026, Costco Executive ($130/yr) breaks even fastest on heavy grocery plus gas spend, Sam's Club Plus ($110/yr) wins for households that shop online often and value free shipping plus Scan and Go, and BJ's Club+ ($110/yr) wins for East Coast families who lean on manufacturer coupons and smaller pack sizes. Household size matters: a family of four typically clears the break-even at any of the three, so the tie-breaker is location, gas volume, and coupon habit.

Add ShopBack Extension

Install the browser extension for auto coupons and cashback reminders.

Download ShopBack App

Get the app to earn cashback and manage rewards on mobile.

Scan QR or download belowScan QR or download below
Get it on the App StoreDownload on Google Play

Related articles

Costco Executive vs Sam's Club Plus vs BJ's Perks Rewards for US 2026: Which Warehouse Club Tier Pays for Itself

Costco Executive vs Sam's Club Plus vs BJ's Perks Rewards for US 2026: Which Warehouse Club Tier Pays for Itself

For US shoppers in 2026, Costco Executive ($130/yr) is the strongest reward rate at 2% capped at $1,250, Sam's Club Plus ($110/yr) has the best gas savings plus free shipping with Sam's Cash 2% capped at $750, and BJ's Club+ ($110/yr) wins on coupon stacking and East Coast grocery breadth. The break-even on the upgrade tier is roughly $3,250 of annual club spend for Costco and $3,000 for Sam's.

Costco vs Sam's Club vs Walmart for Groceries in 2026

For a US family of four, Costco wins on high-turnover staples and prepared foods, Sam's Club wins on scan-and-go convenience and cheaper base membership, Walmart wins when the trip is small or urgent. Here is the annual math on when each pays off and where the warehouse fee breaks even.

Kirkland vs Member's Mark vs Wellsley Farms: Which Warehouse Private Label Wins in 2026

Kirkland vs Member's Mark vs Wellsley Farms: Which Warehouse Private Label Wins in 2026

For a US household in 2026, Kirkland Signature (Costco) has the broadest category coverage and highest brand prestige, Member's Mark (Sam's Club) leads on price-per-unit on many staples with strong national-brand parity, and Wellsley Farms (BJ's Wholesale) punches above its store count on baked goods and prepared food. Category winners vary sharply, no single brand wins across the board.

US Back-to-School 2026 Sale Calendar: When Laptops, Dorm Gear, Kids' Clothes, and Supplies Actually Hit Their Deepest Cuts

US Back-to-School 2026 Sale Calendar: When Laptops, Dorm Gear, Kids' Clothes, and Supplies Actually Hit Their Deepest Cuts

The full US 2026 back-to-school sale calendar. Laptops peak the last week of July and mid-August. Kids' clothes at Old Navy, Gap, and Target discount hardest August 4 to 18. Dorm gear at Target Deal Days, Bed Bath, and Walmart clears late July. Supplies at Staples and Target hit their real cuts August 2 to 10.

Shop, book trips, and play games to earn Cashback

Shop, book trips, and play games to earn Cashback

No points, no credits. Just real cash. Withdraw to your Paypal account and spend however you like.

Complete quests, score bigger savings

Complete quests, score bigger savings

Unlock more rewards by completing limited time shopping quests

Costco Executive vs Sam's Club Plus vs BJ's Club+ for a US Family of Four in 2026: Which Warehouse Club Pays Back the Fee? | ShopBack Blog