Where Can I Buy a Butter Squishy in the US in 2026?

Published: 8 October 2026 · Author: Jean Goh, ShopBack

ShopBack US is a free cashback app and website. You start on ShopBack, shop at stores like Target, Walmart or Temu as usual, and get part of what you spent back as cash. Sign up for ShopBack before you order.

---

Where can I buy a butter squishy?

You can buy a butter squishy at Target, Walmart and Temu in the US, and each suits a different kind of shopper. Target can be the easiest choice if you want a branded toy you can pick up at a nearby store, Walmart has the widest range of jumbo slow-rise versions from Marketplace sellers, and Temu suits shoppers filling a cart with several fidget toys.

Store	What you usually find	Delivery options	Watch out for
Target	Sunny Days Squeeezy Butter in the Squishy Fidget Toys aisle	Pickup, delivery and shipping, shown on the listing	Stock can sell out in local stores
Walmart	Jumbo slow-rise PU foam butter sticks and multi-packs, many from Marketplace sellers	Shipping; pickup and delivery depend on the seller	Seller shipping fees and longer delivery dates
Temu	Many sellers offering butter stick squishies and squishy bundles	Shipping only, with delivery dates shown at checkout	Size and material vary by seller

Product details in this table are taken from the stores' own listings at the time of writing.

Other stores on ShopBack US worth checking for squishy and fidget toys include eBay and AliExpress.

---

Butter squishy: what is it, and which type do you want?

A butter squishy is a fidget toy shaped like a stick of butter that you squeeze, knead or press for stress relief and sensory play. Sellers make two main types:

• Slow-rise foam butter squishies. Made of soft PU foam. You press them flat and they rise back slowly. A Walmart Marketplace listing describes a 14oz jumbo butter stick of this type that is over 10 inches long.
• Squeeze butter toys. Made of rubbery materials that spring back faster. Target's Squeeezy Butter is this kind: Target lists its materials as TPR (thermoplastic rubber) and PVA (polyvinyl alcohol), and the product description says it can be squished, stretched or kneaded and bounces back to its original shape.

If you want the slow, satisfying sink and rise you see in videos, look for "slow rise" and "PU foam" in the listing. If the toy is for a child who will stretch and knead it hard, a squeeze type is usually the sturdier pick.

---

Butter squishy 2026: what to check before you buy

In 2026 the details that matter most on a butter squishy are size, material, age rating and the total cost with shipping. A short checklist:

1. Size. Jumbo butter sticks are usually over 10 inches long. Target lists the Squeeezy Butter at 10.2 by 2.2 by 2.2 inches.
2. Material. PU foam for slow-rise, TPR or similar for squeeze toys.
3. Age rating. Target lists a suggested age of 3 years and up for the Squeeezy Butter. Some Marketplace listings are marketed to teens and adults, so check before buying for a young child.
4. Seller. On Walmart.com, check whether the item is sold by Walmart or by a Marketplace seller. Marketplace sellers set their own shipping fees, and on a small toy the shipping can cost as much as the toy.
5. Reviews. Read recent reviews for notes on smell, air pockets or tearing, which vary from product to product.

---

Butter squishy best deals in the US for 2026

The best deal on a butter squishy in the US usually comes from comparing the total cost with shipping, buying several toys in one order, and going through ShopBack before you pay. Practical steps:

1. Compare the total, not the sticker. Add shipping to the item price, especially on Marketplace and Temu listings.
2. Bundle. Multi-packs and one larger cart usually cost less per toy than several small orders, and help you reach a store's free shipping minimum. Walmart offers free shipping on orders of $35 or more for non-members, at the time of writing.
3. Use the store's own programme. Target Circle is Target's free loyalty programme with member deals. Walmart+ is Walmart's paid membership at $98 a year or $12.95 a month, at the time of writing.
4. Time it. Fidget toys are popular stocking stuffers. Black Friday falls on 27 November 2026 and Cyber Monday on 30 November 2026. See our sale calendar for other dates.
5. Check ShopBack before you check out. Open the Target, Walmart or Temu page on ShopBack US, activate, and check out in the same session.

---

Target vs Walmart butter squishy price comparison 2026

Neither Target nor Walmart is always cheaper for a butter squishy; Target usually wins on easy pickup of a branded toy, while Walmart usually wins on choice of jumbo and multi-pack versions. The price on a given toy depends on the day, the seller and stock.

	Target	Walmart
Typical product	Sunny Days Squeeezy Butter, a TPR squeeze toy	Slow-rise PU foam butter sticks and bundles, often from Marketplace sellers
Official programme	Target Circle, free to join, with member deals	Walmart+, $98 a year or $12.95 a month, at the time of writing
Price protection	Price Match Guarantee when Target's own price drops on an identical eligible item within 14 days	Check Walmart's current policy
Shipping	Pickup, delivery and shipping options on the listing	Free shipping on orders of $35 or more for non-members; Marketplace seller fees vary
ShopBack	Check ShopBack, then shop Target	Go through ShopBack, then order from Walmart

Target asks for proof of the current Target price for a price match and does not accept screenshots, so check Target's price match policy for the full rules.

---

Target, Walmart and Temu butter squishies in the US: how to buy

To buy a butter squishy at Target, Walmart or Temu in the US for less, go through ShopBack before you check out, then shop as usual. The steps in order:

1. Sign in to ShopBack US on the app, website or browser extension.
2. Open the Target, Walmart or Temu store page and activate.
3. Search the store for "butter squishy" and check the size, material, age rating and seller.
4. Compare the total with shipping against the other stores.
5. Check out in the same session. Your cashback shows on your ShopBack account once the order is tracked.

On Temu, you are buying from individual sellers through the Temu app or website, so the same product can come in different sizes and materials. Read each listing's details and recent reviews, and check the delivery date shown at checkout if you need the toy by a set day.

---

How ShopBack lowers the price of a butter squishy

Before you check out, go through ShopBack to get a post-purchase discount on the order. Cashback lowers what you actually pay for an order. It comes back as cash, so it works like a discount on the price, not like points or miles.

Your effective price is what you pay minus the cash ShopBack returns. For example, on a $25 order of fidget toys at an illustrative 5%, $1.25 comes back, so the effective price is $23.75. The 5% here is only an example; check the live rate on the store's ShopBack page before you buy. Walmart works differently: ShopBack pays a fixed cash amount on eligible Walmart orders, so your effective price is what you pay at checkout minus that amount; the live amount is on Walmart's ShopBack page.

To make sure it tracks:

• Start on ShopBack before you add items to the cart.
• Do not switch to a coupon site partway through.
• Check the store's terms on its ShopBack page, as some products, sellers or categories may be excluded.

---

Frequently asked questions

Where can I buy a butter squishy?

In the US you can buy a butter squishy at Target, Walmart and Temu. Target sells the Squeeezy Butter by Sunny Days in its squishy fidget toys aisle, Walmart lists jumbo slow-rise foam butter squishies from Marketplace sellers, and Temu has many sellers offering butter stick squishies. Check ShopBack before you check out so the order costs you less.

What is a butter squishy?

A butter squishy is a fidget toy shaped like a stick of butter that you squeeze for stress relief and sensory play. Most come in two types: slow-rise foam versions made of PU foam that sink and slowly rise back, and squeeze toys made of materials like TPR that bounce back faster. Many jumbo versions are over 10 inches long.

Does Target sell butter squishies?

Yes. Target lists the Sunny Days Squeeezy Butter Shape Fidget Toy under Toys and Games, Fidget Toys, Squishy Fidget Toys. Target gives its size as 10.2 by 2.2 by 2.2 inches, its weight as 1.05 pounds, its suggested age as 3 years and up, and its materials as TPR and PVA, at the time of writing. Target offers pickup, delivery and shipping options on the listing.

Does Walmart sell butter squishies?

Yes. Walmart.com lists butter squishies, including jumbo slow-rise PU foam butter sticks over 10 inches long, many of them sold and shipped by Marketplace sellers. Marketplace sellers set their own shipping fees and delivery dates, so check who sells the item and the total cost before you add it to your cart.

Is Target or Walmart cheaper for a butter squishy?

Neither is always cheaper. A Target listing sold by Target may be easier to pick up in store, while Walmart often has more Marketplace choices whose shipping fees vary by seller. Compare the item price plus shipping at both on the day you buy, then go through ShopBack before you check out.

Is a butter squishy from Temu worth it?

A Temu butter squishy can be good value if you are buying several fidget toys at once. Temu is a marketplace, so size, material and quality vary by seller, and delivery usually takes longer than store pickup. Read the listing's size and material details and recent reviews before you order.

What age is a butter squishy for?

It depends on the product. Target lists a suggested age of 3 years and up for the Squeeezy Butter, while some Marketplace listings are marketed for teens and adults. Always check the age rating on the specific listing, especially for small children.

What is the difference between a slow-rise and a squeeze butter squishy?

A slow-rise butter squishy is usually made of PU foam that you press flat and watch slowly return to shape. A squeeze butter toy is usually made of a rubbery material like TPR and springs back faster, which makes it better for kneading and stretching. Pick slow-rise for a calm, satisfying squish and squeeze types for active fidgeting.

When is the best time to buy a butter squishy?

Fidget toys are popular stocking stuffers, so holiday sales around Black Friday (27 November 2026) and Cyber Monday (30 November 2026) are usually a good time to buy. Buying earlier also helps with Marketplace and Temu orders, which can take longer to arrive.

How does ShopBack make a butter squishy cheaper?

Before you check out, go through ShopBack US to get a post-purchase discount on the order at Target, Walmart or Temu. Cashback lowers what you actually pay for an order. It comes back as cash, so it works like a discount on the price, not like points or miles. Check the live rate on the store's ShopBack page before you buy.

---

Key takeaways

• You can buy a butter squishy at Target, Walmart and Temu in the US.
• Target's Sunny Days Squeeezy Butter is a 10.2 inch TPR squeeze toy suggested for ages 3 and up, per Target's listing.
• Walmart.com has jumbo slow-rise PU foam butter sticks, many from Marketplace sellers with their own shipping fees.
• Compare the total with shipping, bundle toys in one order, and look at Black Friday and Cyber Monday.
• Check ShopBack US before you check out at Target, Walmart or Temu so the order costs less.

---

Related reads

• Temu Discounts in the US
• Walmart Discounts in the US
• The US Sale Calendar: When to Buy What
• Activate Cashback Before Buying
• How to Find Promo Codes That Work

Shop fidget toys through ShopBack US: Target · Walmart · Temu · eBay · AliExpress

---

Disclaimer

The views in this article are those of the author and are for general information only. Product details, store prices, shipping fees, price match rules and membership benefits can change; check the store's listing before you buy. Cashback rates on ShopBack vary by store and campaign; check the current rate and terms on each store's ShopBack page before you shop.